Toasting to the best crumbs around!

Cottage bakery specializing in cookies, cake pops, and pie pops. Looking forward to baking your best bites.

A red tray filled with decorated sugar cookies shaped like strawberries, daisies, and hearts, some with pink or white icing and green leaves, held by a person wearing a pink checkered shirt outdoors among green bushes and pink flowers.

Everyday Cookie Flavors

Comfort:

  • Chocolate Chip

  • M & M

  • Sprinkle

Sugar:

  • Almond

  • Cookies & Cream

  • Vanilla

Everyday Cake Pop Flavors

  • Chocolate

  • Cookies & Cream

  • Funfetti

  • Strawberry

  • Vanilla

Everyday Pie Pop Flavors

  • Apple

  • Pumpkin

Decorative cookies in pastel pink, purple, and white colors with designs including a baby bottle, a dress with angel wings, a bow, and the name Lucy Jo on a scalloped edge plaque, arranged on a light yellow fabric with green bushes in the background.
Colorful cake pops on a white display stand, decorated with small bows, in pastel shades of pink, blue, yellow, orange, and green, arranged in a circular pattern. A vase with pink flowers is seen in the background.
Colorful decorated cookies shaped like seashells, starfish, and mermaid tails with pastel pink, mint green, lavender, and peach icing, some with polka dots and textured patterns, on a gray surface.

Seasonal Menu

Close-up of a smore's cookie with graham crackers, chocolate, and marshmallow.

Smore’s Comfort Cookie

$36/ dozen

1 dozen minimum.

Cookies decorated with golfing theme designs including a golf shirt, a golf hole with a flag, a golf cart, and a golf ball on green grass.

Tee-Riffic Dad Sugar Cookies

$16/ 4 pack

Available as boxes of 4, 8, or 12 cookies.

Vanilla flavor only.

Pricing

$36/dozen

Custom cake pops with the flavor of your choosing. Mix of flavors available on orders of 2+ dozen. 1 dozen minimum.

Cake Pops

Custom Sugar Cookies

$48/dozen

Custom sugar cookies with the flavor of your choosing. Mix of flavors available on orders of 2+ dozen. 1 dozen minimum.

Comfort Cookies

$36/dozen

Comfort style cookies with the flavor of your choosing. Mix of flavors available on orders of 2+ dozen. ½ dozen minimum.

Cookies

$36/dozen

Baked pie pops with the flavor of your choosing. Mix of flavors available on orders of 2+ dozen. 1 dozen minimum.

Pie Pops

Decorated space-themed cookies on a black tray, including planets, stars, an astronaut, and rockets, against a starry galaxy background.
Decorative cookies with spider web and superhero face designs, with some labeled 'JOEY' on a red tablecloth.
Cookies decorated as black and white polka dot dresses, individually wrapped in clear plastic with red bows, arranged in a white box on a red surface.

Policies

  • 50% non-refundable deposit required within 48 hours of order acceptance to hold your date. Remaining balance due the day before pick-up.

  • Order acceptance will be sent via email with an invoice.

  • Custom orders received less than 2 weeks before pick-up date may incur a $15 rush fee.

  • Pick-up location at the “Epicenter at Agritopia” parking lot.

  • Delivery may be available dependent on distance.

Order Form